Court Session 3
Nov 08, 2026 02:01
· 34:55
· English
· Whisper Turbo
· 8 Qof-dheer
Qoraalkani wuxuu dhacayaa 29 maalmood.
Kordhinta kaydinta joogtada ah →
Soo bandhigida oo keliya
0:07
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Big sleeves and sharp edges.
0:09
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Please be seated.
0:11
S…
Speaker 2 (Court Session 3)
Crown,
0:18
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
ready to proceed today?
0:20
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Yep.
0:21
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Of course,
0:22
S…
Speaker 2 (Court Session 3)
my Lord.
0:22
S…
Speaker 2 (Court Session 3)
Thank
0:26
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
you. Defence?
0:27
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Ready to proceed,
0:32
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
my Lord.
0:33
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
No.
0:34
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
As I understand from the last day,
0:36
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
both the Crown and Defence have arrested their cases,
0:39
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
and we are ready for summations.
0:41
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
We'll allow the Crown to proceed first with their summation.
0:45
S…
Speaker 2 (Court Session 3)
Of
0:52
S…
Speaker 2 (Court Session 3)
course, my Lord.
0:56
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
My lord and honourable members of the jury,
0:58
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
thank you for your time considering this case.
1:00
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
As the Crown has shown through evidence and testimony,
1:03
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
the two accused,
1:04
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Matlock Manitoba and Mason Perry,
1:06
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
are beyond a reasonable doubt guilty of break and enter in relation
1:10
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
to a dwelling house to commit the indictable offence of robbery.
1:12
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
The Crown also proved beyond a reasonable doubt the accused committed the indictable offence of
1:16
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
robbery against the victim,
1:17
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Monty Hall.
1:19
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Both of the accused were placed unlawfully in Monty Hall's residence through evidence and testimony
1:23
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
of three witnesses.
1:24
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Could you just slow down just
1:28
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
a touch so that they can hang on every word?
1:31
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Items which were forcibly taken from Monty
1:35
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Hall during the robbery were found in the accused's possessions,
1:38
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
and weapons used to commit the robbery were found discarded in a dumpster a very short
1:42
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
distance from the accused.
1:43
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
All of the evidence and testimonies point the fact that the accused did
1:47
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
commit the above charges beyond any reasonable doubt.
1:51
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Monty Hall was sober,
1:52
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
had decent recall of the events,
1:54
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
but was obviously affected by the violent and terrifying crime committed against him.
1:57
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
He was certain of the fact the front door and the back door opened at the same time.
2:01
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
This supports a planned break and enter and robbery.
2:03
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Annie Hall is an independent witness,
2:06
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
sober, and had a good,
2:08
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
clear view of the individuals in the backyard.
2:09
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Officer York was detailed and thorough,
2:12
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
and with police dog Macy is an expert in tracking.
2:14
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Scott Anderson,
2:16
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
while testifying,
2:17
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
was very unsure of many things.
2:19
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
such as times and dates.
2:20
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
He also had no knowledge of what occurred after Mason Perry left his house and
2:24
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
is also there to help the two accused and is such not an independent witness.
2:27
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
The witness,
2:29
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Monty Hall, identified Matlock,
2:30
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Manitoba during the robbery after forcing his way into the house and threatening him
2:34
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
with a weapon.
2:35
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Matlock was also identified by Mason Perry fleeing the house around the time of the break
2:39
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
and enter and he was also known to be waiting for Mason Perry with his vehicle near the Monty
2:43
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Hall residence.
2:43
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
He was found to have been fleeing the scene immediately after
2:48
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
the B &E and robbery.
2:49
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Again?
2:50
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Oh, sorry.
2:50
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Slow down just a touch.
2:52
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
And found to possess the victim's wallet and
2:56
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
ID stolen during the break and enter robbery,
2:58
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
within minutes of the offence and within two blocks.
3:01
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
There is no reasonable explanation for having these items unless
3:05
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
he had committed the robbery.
3:05
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
The evidence which proves Mason Perry committed the crime includes she
3:10
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
was in possession of a watch that the victim,
3:11
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Monty Hall, testified was his watch.
3:13
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
And there is no reasonable explanation as
3:17
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
to why she would have his watch unless she had taken it from him during the robbery.
3:22
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Annie Hall also saw two individuals fleeing the house,
3:25
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
which is consistent with Mason Perry's statement that she was at the victim's
3:29
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
house and ran with Matlock.
3:30
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Annie Hall is also an independent witness,
3:33
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
as she has no ties to either party and nothing to gain.
3:35
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Mason Perry's post -offense conduct
3:42
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
also shows her guilt,
3:43
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
as there was no reason for her to run with Matlock unless she was also guilty of committing the offence,
3:47
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
as she could have waited for Matlock by the vehicle if she was going for a ride.
3:52
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
This evidence was presented to the court and proves beyond any reasonable doubt that the two accused committed
3:56
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
the offence of break and entering and committing robbery.
3:57
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
That's all,
3:59
S…
Speaker 3 (Court Session 3)
Millard.
4:00
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Thank you very much.
4:02
S…
Speaker 2 (Court Session 3)
Ladies and gentlemen
4:12
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
of the jury, I would like to go through with you chronologically the oral and physical
4:16
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
evidence that has been considered during this trial.
4:18
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
This has been a case of misidentification.
4:21
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
I would like to discuss the alleged victim,
4:24
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Mr.
4:24
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Monty Hull,
4:25
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
stated both the accused that entered his home were male.
4:29
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
So, ladies and gentlemen,
4:30
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
how is it possible that my client,
4:32
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Ms.
4:32
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Mason Perry,
4:33
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
was even there?
4:34
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
If Mr.
4:36
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Hall believes both the accused were male,
4:37
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
how can we believe his testimony is credible when we have a male and female
4:41
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
here today?
4:42
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
In fact,
4:43
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
the only description he gave was one of the accusers wearing a mask,
4:47
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
and that individual was smaller than him.
4:49
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
The man wearing the ski mask,
4:52
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
according to Mr.
4:53
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Hall, took his wallet.
4:55
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
According to Constable York,
4:57
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
the individual with the wallet...
5:00
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
was our client,
5:01
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Matlock Manitoba,
5:02
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
and Mr.
5:03
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Hall identified him as the accused without the mask on.
5:06
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
As you can see,
5:09
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Ms.
5:10
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Perry is wearing glasses and was wearing
5:14
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
glasses when she was taken into custody.
5:16
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
There is no identification from Mr.
5:19
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Hall about the individuals in the house wearing glasses that day.
5:23
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Ladies and gentlemen,
5:24
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
for those of you who have studied eyewitness testimony,
5:26
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
our client has been identified from a very short interaction,
5:31
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
and he was under extreme duress,
5:33
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
which of course distorts the memory.
5:35
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
In relation to the physical evidence presented in court,
5:38
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
I have two questions.
5:39
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Where is the ski mask,
5:41
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
and where are the fingerprints of my client on the knife and gun?
5:44
S…
Speaker 5 (Court Session 3)
Mr.
5:46
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Hall testified under oath that his watch,
5:48
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
that this watch in court today,
5:50
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
might not be his.
5:53
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
We believe that this watch was unlawfully taken and belongs to
5:57
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Ms. Perry's father,
5:58
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
like she had stated numerous times as a police officer.
6:00
S…
Speaker 2 (Court Session 3)
Now,
6:02
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
ladies and gentlemen, I would like to take you through Constable York.
6:05
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Constable York stated in his notes that he seized a knife and gun an
6:09
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
hour and 20 minutes before Mr.
6:12
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Hall even stated that his home was invaded.
6:13
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
That is impossible.
6:16
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Constable York also stated that Mr.
6:18
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Hall and Annie Hall identified both the weapons together.
6:22
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Well, Miss Annie Hall testified she didn't even leave her house,
6:26
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
nor was she able to identify the two individuals very well.
6:30
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Regarding Constable York's statement in court,
6:34
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
he says he saw two figures running out of the backyard.
6:37
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
This is impossible as Annie Hall,
6:40
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
who witnessed the two individuals running out of the backyard,
6:44
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
and then called the police.
6:49
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Constable York would like to have you believe that it is an offence in Canada for
6:54
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
a female to be wearing a male's watch.
6:56
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
Constable York had no reasonable grounds to take that watch off my client's wrist.
7:00
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
I submit to you,
7:01
S…
Speaker 4 (Court Session 3)
ladies and gentlemen, that Constable York is wrong.
7:03
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury,
7:07
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
it is not the job of the defence to prove innocence,
7:09
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
but rather the job of the Crown to prove beyond reasonable doubt guilt.
7:15
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
Throughout this case,
7:16
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
we as the defense strongly believe the Crown has not succeeded in doing this task.
7:20
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
Our clients,
7:21
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
Mason Perry and Matlock Manitoba,
7:23
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
have been victims of inadequate investigation coupled with unreliable
7:27
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
eyewitness reports.
7:28
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
In regards to Mr.
7:30
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
Manitoba, being in possession of another person's wallet in and of itself does
7:34
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
not mean he is guilty of the charges he is being pressed against.
7:37
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
Just as a woman wearing a male's
7:41
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
watch is not an offense within Canada.
7:46
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
Throughout the hearing,
7:47
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
you heard multiple cases of uncertainty from witnesses.
7:49
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
But from our client,
7:53
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
Mason Perry,
7:54
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
there was no uncertainty of the events which occurred.
7:56
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
To close,
7:58
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
in this day and age of DNA research,
8:00
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
expertise in forensics,
8:02
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
and advances we have made in technology in the field of forensics identification,
8:06
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
we find it odd that not a single piece of forensic evidence,
8:09
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
either from the weapons,
8:10
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
are accused were to allegedly have that evening.
8:13
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
or from the house they were allegedly inside,
8:16
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
was entered as evidence in court these last days.
8:19
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
We would ask that you find our clients,
8:22
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
Matlock, Manitoba,
8:23
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
and Mason Perry,
8:24
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
not guilty of all charges.
8:25
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
We respectfully submit that the Crown has not proven their case beyond
8:30
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
a reasonable doubt.
8:30
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
Thank you,
8:31
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
ladies and gentlemen.
8:32
S…
Speaker 2 (Court Session 3)
Members
8:40
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
of the jury.
8:43
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
You've heard the testimony over the last two days,
8:47
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
two previous days,
8:48
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
and you've also heard the summations put
8:52
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
forward by the Crown and the defense in this matter.
8:56
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
In a moment,
8:58
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
I'm going to be sending you to make
9:02
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
a decision with respect to these events
9:06
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
and make a decision as to whether Mr.
9:10
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Perry...
9:11
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
and Ms.
9:15
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Perry and Mr.
9:16
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Matlock Manitoba are guilty of
9:20
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
the offences and the charges before them.
9:23
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
I want to ask you to consider certain
9:27
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
things.
9:28
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
The charge is that on
9:32
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
the 15th day of January 2016 near the city of Lethbridge in the province of
9:36
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Alberta, did break and enter a place to a dwelling house
9:41
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
with the intent to commit an indictable offence therein,
9:43
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
and that indictable offence is robbery.
9:46
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
And the other count,
9:50
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
the second count,
9:51
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
is that on the 15th day of January 2016,
9:56
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
I renewed the city of Lethbridge and the province over,
9:58
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
did commit robbery of Maudie.
10:00
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
call, contrary to section 344 of the criminal code.
10:03
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
So,
10:03
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
in these charges,
10:05
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
you have to look at all the elements that
10:09
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
are in the offense.
10:10
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Now,
10:11
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
just to quickly break and enter.
10:14
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
To break is not necessarily to damage.
10:18
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Now the Crown has alluded that there was damage to both doors
10:22
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
of Mr.
10:24
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Hall's residence.
10:24
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
However, breaking means essentially crossing a threshold
10:29
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
into a premises where you have not had permission
10:33
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
or you have not been invited in.
10:35
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
So breaking and
10:39
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
the entering.
10:40
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
The robbery...
10:42
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Different than theft means that there has to be an
10:46
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
element of either violence
10:54
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
or a threat of violence towards the
10:58
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
victim.
10:59
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
So that must be proven.
11:02
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
You also have to...
11:04
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
prove that the evidence given by the Crown with respect
11:09
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
to the date,
11:09
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
time,
11:10
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
and the jurisdiction of this court is
11:14
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
also taken into consideration.
11:17
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Now,
11:18
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
a couple of other things that we have to look at as well
11:22
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
is the word intent.
11:26
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
And intent means mens rea,
11:29
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
it means a guilty mind,
11:31
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
an acting,
11:32
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
operating mind.
11:34
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
In other words,
11:35
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
there had to be some idea that they intended to
11:39
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
do what they did,
11:41
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
not that this was just something that they came across.
11:44
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
So there has to be the mental capacity in
11:48
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
this case.
11:49
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
So those are the main
11:53
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
issues.
11:56
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
With the robbery,
11:57
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
to commit the robbery,
11:58
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
as I say, compared to theft,
12:00
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
is the violence or the intent to
12:06
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
commit violence or a threat of violence.
12:08
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
So those are the things that you need to consider.
12:11
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
The other part is that in
12:16
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
our...
12:17
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
justice system in a criminal matter unlike
12:21
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
a civil matter you must find guilt beyond
12:25
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
a reasonable doubt reasonableness is what would
12:30
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
a reasonable person do or believe in the same circumstances
12:34
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
so beyond a reasonable doubt is what the crown must
12:38
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
prove as it was stated by the defense
12:42
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
The Crown is under the obligation to prove all the elements
12:46
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
of the case beyond a reasonable doubt.
12:48
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
If you cannot come to a decision,
12:51
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
a unanimous decision,
12:53
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
that these offenses
12:57
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
did take place and they took place by both
13:02
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
the accused Perry and Manitoba,
13:05
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
then you must render a decision of not
13:09
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
guilty in this matter.
13:10
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
So at this point,
13:12
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
we're going to adjourn.
13:14
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
There will be someone that will be taking the jury
13:18
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
to a jury room.
13:20
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
The court clerk will take you to the jury room.
13:24
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
And due to our circumstance here,
13:27
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
you will have approximately 15 minutes,
13:29
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
at which time the...
13:33
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Court clerk will come back and check to see how
13:38
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
you're doing with your decision.
13:40
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
In this case,
13:41
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
I don't want just guilty or not guilty to
13:45
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
the accused.
13:46
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
I also want you to tell me,
13:48
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
the jury foreperson,
13:50
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
who is that?
13:50
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
The foreperson,
13:53
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
I will expect that when you give that verdict,
13:58
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
you tell me why your jury has
14:02
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
made that decision.
14:03
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Okay, so until 15 minutes
14:08
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
from now would be approximately,
14:09
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
let's say,
14:13
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
20 to the hour,
14:15
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
we'll reconvene.
14:18
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
So until that time,
14:19
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
we are adjourned.
14:20
S…
Speaker 2 (Court Session 3)
Please be
14:25
S…
Speaker 2 (Court Session 3)
seated. The
14:33
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
jury is all
14:37
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
back.
14:37
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Mr.
14:39
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Foreperson,
14:39
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
would you please...
14:42
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
There's been two matters that you were charged with
14:46
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
in this case.
14:47
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
You have two accused and you have two counts.
14:52
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
So what I'm going to ask you first
14:57
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
is to have...
15:00
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Mason Perry,
15:01
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
please stand and face the jury.
15:02
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Mr.
15:07
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Foreperson,
15:07
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
in this situation,
15:10
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
regarding count number one,
15:12
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
which is the break -and -enter dwelling house with the intent to
15:16
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
commit therein an indictable offense of robbery,
15:18
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
how do you find this accused?
15:21
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
I'm not guilty.
15:23
S…
Speaker 2 (Court Session 3)
Okay.
15:24
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
And on the second count of did
15:29
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
commit the robbery of Monty Hall,
15:31
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
contrary to Section 344,
15:33
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
how do you find?
15:33
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
Okay.
15:36
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
And as requested,
15:40
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
could you please explain to the court why
15:45
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
you found Ms.
15:47
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Perry not guilty?
15:48
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
We did not believe that there was enough evidence to prove
15:52
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
without a reasonable doubt that she had committed.
15:56
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
their offenses.
15:57
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
Yeah,
15:59
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
we just didn't.
16:03
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Okay. For what reasons did you find that
16:08
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
there was reasonable doubt?
16:09
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
Just in the ways that there was not.
16:12
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
Specifics.
16:16
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
Specifics like,
16:16
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
say, the walk here.
16:17
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
Okay.
16:42
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
I'm going to leave my sentencing,
16:46
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
et cetera, until Mr.
16:49
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Manitoba is dealt with.
16:51
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Ms.
16:52
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Perry, you may sit down for now.
16:54
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
On the second
16:58
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
accused in this matter,
17:00
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Matlock Perry.
17:01
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Mr.
17:02
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Perry, would you please stand and face the jury.
17:04
S…
Speaker 2 (Court Session 3)
Mr.
17:06
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Foreperson.
17:07
S…
Speaker 8 (Court Session 3)
Sorry,
17:09
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Matlock, Manitoba.
17:10
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Sorry.
17:10
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Thank you.
17:15
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Mr.
17:15
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Manitoba faced the jury,
17:17
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
and in this case,
17:18
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
on count number one,
17:19
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Mr.
17:20
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Foreperson, how did the jury find?
17:21
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
Guilty.
17:23
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
On the second charge
17:27
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
of robbery of Monty Hall,
17:29
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
how did you find?
17:30
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
Okay,
17:32
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
and again,
17:33
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
giving some specifics,
17:36
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
why did you find?
17:37
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
Size,
17:44
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
stature.
17:45
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
They were able to identify him
17:49
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
specifically.
17:50
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
The dog was able to track directly
17:54
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
located,
17:55
S…
Speaker 7 (Court Session 3)
following the send.
18:11
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Thank you,
18:13
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Mr.
18:13
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Foreperson.
18:14
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Mr.
18:17
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Manitoba,
18:18
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
you may sit.
18:19
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
And Ms.
18:20
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Perry, would you please stand?
18:22
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Ms.
18:24
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Perry, jury in this matter has
18:29
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
found you not guilty on both counts and therefore free
18:34
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
to go.
18:35
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
You have not been kept in custody.
18:36
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
With respect,
18:41
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
To the watch in this situation,
18:45
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
the exhibit of the watch,
18:46
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
I am going to order,
18:49
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
saying there is no indication that this watch was
18:53
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
the property of Mr.
18:55
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Hall and that there is a situation where the
18:59
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
accused has not been found guilty of possession of
19:04
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
that instrument, I am going to order that that watch be returned to Ms.
19:08
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Perry.
19:09
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
by the court upon completion.
19:11
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
You are free to go,
19:13
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Ms.
19:14
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Perry. Mr.
19:16
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Manitoba, you've been found guilty
19:20
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
of both counts in this matter,
19:23
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
and we are going to set
19:28
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
a date for how
19:34
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
long would you need to prepare a summary?
19:38
S…
Speaker 2 (Court Session 3)
Two months,
19:42
S…
Speaker 6 (Court Session 3)
you're on, or my lord.
19:43
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Okay, I think that's a little bit long.
19:47
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
We are going to release
19:51
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Mr.
19:53
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Manitoba on his
19:57
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
own recognizance at this point.
20:00
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
to be back in court for sentencing in one month from
20:04
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
today's date,
20:04
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
as long as the Monday,
20:08
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
one month from now.
20:09
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Until that time,
20:12
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
you will be required to
20:16
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
report weekly to the Lethbridge Mock Police Service,
20:19
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
and the bailiff will give you the information
20:24
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
with respect to that.
20:25
S…
Speaker 2 (Court Session 3)
Okay,
20:26
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
other than that, this court is now adjourned.
20:35
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
For the purpose of time,
20:37
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
if you want to just have a seat,
20:39
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
I know.
20:40
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Mr.
20:45
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Bartley has asked me to make some comments with
20:49
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
respect to the cases,
20:51
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
your participation.
20:56
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
First of all,
20:57
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
I'm not a judge,
20:58
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
okay?
20:59
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
I've taught this course numerous times.
21:03
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
I've also had a lot of experience in my previous life in
21:08
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
policing to testify or be in court on a lot of occasions.
21:12
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
So the whole idea of this trial and this exercise,
21:17
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
which is new this semester,
21:19
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
is to try to help you
21:22
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
succeed when it comes down to your next two trials.
21:24
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Hopefully this has given you some idea of exactly
21:29
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
what is going to be expected of you and the process.
21:32
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
This is based on an actual case,
21:36
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Marie's,
21:37
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
and it was set up to help you learn not to admonish,
21:41
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
okay?
21:41
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
So that's not,
21:43
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
but I am going to make some,
21:44
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
you are allowed to make mistakes without the consequences,
21:48
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
and that's what we're really doing here.
21:50
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Some took advantage of this opportunity more than others.
21:54
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Sometimes opportunities will...
21:59
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Go to character and attitude.
22:01
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
And if it was no marks equals
22:05
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
no marks,
22:06
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
no effort, then that's up to you and that's your own personal decisions.
22:09
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
But this is an opportunity.
22:12
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Don't waste this opportunity.
22:14
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Take what you've learned from here regardless of what
22:18
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
role you played or if you played a specific role.
22:21
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Look at what happened with your peers and how things worked out.
22:26
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
You had an opportunity to work with a senior prosecutor.
22:29
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
That is a gift,
22:32
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
an absolute gift,
22:34
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
and I'm sure the people with the Crown
22:38
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
would have understood.
22:39
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
The opportunity to have that sort of mentorship is phenomenal.
22:44
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
Also,
22:47
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
to have...
22:49
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
With Murray,
22:50
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
your instructor,
22:51
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
to have one -on -one mentorship with your instructor in
22:55
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
this day and age and in any sort of post -secondary is phenomenal
23:00
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
in itself.
23:00
S…
Speaker 1 (Court Session 3)
And I know that I'm sure that you've shared that sort of feeling.
Qoraalkan waxaa abuuray AI (u aqoonsiga hadalka otomaatiga ah). Waxay ku jiri kartaa khaladaad — xaqiijin ka dhanka ah audio asalka ah ee isticmaalka muhiimka ah. Xeerka AI
Qiyaas
Riix Summarize in ay soo saaraan AI faahfaahin ka mid ah qoraalkan.
La iskugu soo uruurinayo...
Su'aal AI Ku saabsan this transcript
Su'aal wax kasta oo ku saabsan qoraalkan - AI ka heli doonaa qaybaha la xiriira iyo jawaab.