447782661473adaf675aaf68ab1f6459
Apr 27, 2026 09:42
· 2:15
· English
· Whisper Turbo
· 2 Reproduktory
Tento přepis dnes vyprší.
Upgrade pro trvalé skladování →
Pouze pro zobrazování
0:00
S…
Speaker 1 (447782661473adaf675aaf68ab1f6459)
Yeah, God is dogmatism. Okay, so you think... Assuming God exists. So when I ask you, does God exist, and you say, yes, that's not true? It's true, and I'm assuming it. How is it true? It's true because I believe it's true.
0:11
S…
Speaker 1 (447782661473adaf675aaf68ab1f6459)
I'm a divine command theorist. So, okay. So I just want to make sure I got this right. How do you posit? He's just going to run away from this. When you, when you posit, well, you have to pay like 10 bucks to ask this question. How do you posit the arguments? And then I have to answer to the argument. So if I pose an argument and I give you the justification for my argument, and it seems like the way that you're acting is that you think that that is.
0:32
S…
Speaker 2 (447782661473adaf675aaf68ab1f6459)
incorrect, then you have to pose me a counter. So I said, if I'm wrong, Andrew, you can just prove me wrong like that. Find me a truth claim that isn't fundamentally unjustifiable. Go ahead. How do you find me one truth claim that doesn't fail? First of all,
0:46
S…
Speaker 2 (447782661473adaf675aaf68ab1f6459)
Who posits Agrippa's trilemma is true, Andrew or Erudite? Agrippa's trilemma isn't... This is like saying Euthyphro's dilemma is true. Is Euthyphro's dilemma true? Okay, again, why are you asking me questions about your argument? Because what you're doing, I think you're... I can't tell. I can't tell if you genuinely don't understand Agrippa's trilemma, maybe, or if you're being bad faith. Those are the only two options. How am I being bad faith when you posit an argument and I ask you about it? Hold on, relax, Andrew. I said there's two options. You genuinely don't understand.
1:14
S…
Speaker 1 (447782661473adaf675aaf68ab1f6459)
Or you're being bad faith. Or there's a third option, which is maybe you don't understand. I do understand how dilemmas work in philosophy. Okay, then let's... Are trolley problems true? Agrippa's trilemma... Is like a trolley problem, yeah. Yeah, I just want to make sure. It's a philosophical test of logic. Okay, I got it. So when you're talking about Agrippa's trilemma, would you have any criticisms for this argument that you're making? I can't solve it. That's the point of the dilemma. Okay, so when you say that the...
1:39
S…
Speaker 1 (447782661473adaf675aaf68ab1f6459)
When I ask you, is Agrippa's Trilemma true? I can't solve it. Is it true, though? Is a trolley problem true? Is Euthyphro's Dilemma true?
1:46
S…
Speaker 2 (447782661473adaf675aaf68ab1f6459)
What are we doing right now? Yeah, I think philosophically you can say that the conclusion is true or false. No, no, Agrippa's Trilemma isn't a conclusion. Agrippa's Trilemma is a problem. It's a philosophical problem. Is Euthyphro's Dilemma true? Wait, wait, wait. I'm not talking about it. I'm talking about Agrippa's Trilemma. Yeah, it's a problem in the same way that Euthyphro's Dilemma is. Okay, so walk me through it. Is Trolley Problems true? Walk me through Agrippa's Dilemma. I'll make sure I understand it. Okay, Agrippa's Trilemma posits that no beliefs are justifiable foundationally because they will fail one of three ways. Dogmatism, infinite regression, or circularity.
Tento přepis byl vytvořen AI (automatické rozpoznávání řeči). Může obsahovat chyby?? ověřit proti původnímu zvuku pro kritické použití. Politika AI
Shrnutí
Klikněte na Summarise pro generování AI shrnutí tohoto přepisu.
Shrnuji...
Zeptejte se UI na tento transcript
Zeptejte se na cokoliv o tomto přepisu, najdete příslušné sekce a odpověď.